This article highlights the poetics of Syrian poet Muḥammad al-Māghūṭ (1934-2006) as laying the foundation for a poetic identity enacted as a series of performative contradictions between the empirical and the poetic selves in what amounts to a discourse of “rhetorical sincerity.” This poetic discourse employs a variety of devices to communicate that the irreducibility of Arab life in the present can be contained neither in the polished spheres of art nor in the high tones of political speech-making. Al-Māghūṭ’s forms of engagement, I claim, offers a poetic corollary with Antonio Gramsci’s notion of the “organic intellectual.” By situating his personas close to perceived commonalities of human struggles without entirely subtracting their critical distance, al-Māghūṭ negotiates a modernistic consciousness with values of ṣidq (sincerity) and aṣāla (authenticity) lodged in the Syrian sphere. Part one of the article develops the concept of poetic sincerity and draws the lines of al-Māghūṭ’s cultural battles. Part two examines al-Māghūṭ’s rhythmic irregularities in “al-Qatl” (The Killing) as a key component in accomplishing the non-literary task of his ṣidq. This interpretation will hopefully cement al-Māghūṭ’s contribution in the canon of the Arabic prose poem and elucidate the rationale behind his import for later poetic generations.